Books like Nightfall

To save the two vampire brothers who love her, Elena Gilbert sacrificed her life. Now that a supernatural force has brought Elena back from the dead, all handsome, brooding Stefan wants is to keep her safe. But when he is lured away from Fell's Church, sleek, powerful Damon seizes his chance to win Elena over, unaware of the danger they're both in. A malevolent being has infiltrated the town and is growing stronger. Able to possess Damon at will, the creature is also drawn to Elena and the new power she has acquired. But it's after more than Elena's power: It thirsts for her death. Elena's story continues in shadow souls!

Liked Nightfall by L.J. Smith? Here's what readers who loved it picked up next.

Tempted by P.C. Cast (2008) · 3.96★
Blue Moon by Alyson Noel (2009) · 3.61★
Stargazer by Claudia Gray (2009) · 3.8★
Masquerade by Melissa de la Cruz (2007) · 3.91★
Frostbite by Richelle Mead (2008) · 4.3★
The Dead Girls' Dance by Rachel Caine (2007) · 4.06★
Thirst No. 1: The Last Vampire, Black Blood, and Red Dice by Christopher Pike (1998) · 3.82★
Vampire Kisses by Ellen Schreiber (2003) · 3.69★
Torment by Lauren Kate (2010) · 3.89★
New Moon by Stephenie Meyer (2006) · 3.52★
City of Ashes by Cassandra Clare (2008) · 4.21★
Bloodlines by Richelle Mead (2011) · 4.22★